Sharon A. Collins, MD, pediatrician
Ronald David, M.D., Pediatrician and Medical
Director, D.C. Health and Hospitals Public Benefits Corporation
Jeffrey Moussaieff Masson, Ph.D, former
projects director of the Freud Archives and author of Dogs Never Lie about
Love and When Elephants Weep
Book Description
In this compassionate and compelling book. Dr. Breggin shows why our children need education, not medication. TALKING BACK TO RITALIN empowers parents to transform distracted, disenchanted and energetic children into powerful, confident and brilliant members of the family and society. If you like facts, here's one: children who were prescribed Ritalin in childhood are three times more likely to use cocaine later in life. Don't try to tell me that this is because their "biochemically defective brains" cause them to make bad choices and use drugs. I don't buy it. And I also don't buy that many don't seem to think that ADHD children are our "best and our brightest", as Peter Breggin believes. I have actually found data that says that ADHD tends to disappear once the child is past school age, and that many of these children tend to do well as artisans or at other jobs where they work "on their feet" when they grow up. Albert Einstein is thought to have had ADHD, and a teacher once wrote on his report card, "You'll never amount to anything." What if Einstein had taken Ritalin? Would he have reached his full potential with his brilliant mind altered by speed? I doubt it. Here's another fact: the U.S. makes and consumes 90% of the world's Ritalin. If it were true that "untreated" ADHD led to kids committing crimes, then we'd see a rash of crimes in other countries that don't use Ritalin. Obviously, the pill solution isn't working, because plenty of kids in this country are shooting their classmates and planting bombs in schools. You don't see this in other countries. In two of the school shootings in recent years, the shooter was taking a mind-altering drug. Who's to say that the drug didn't contribute to or even cause the teens' behavior and make them violence-prone? See online biography and comments by Peter Breggin. * * * PETER R. BREGGIN, M. D., is a leading critic of psychiatric drugs and the psycho-pharmaceutical complex. He is a graduate of Harvard College and Case Western Reserve Medical School, and was formerly a teaching fellow at Harvard Medical School and a full-time consultant with the National Institute of Mental Health. He is the director of the Center for the Study of Psychiatry and has been in the full-time practice of psychiatry in Bethesda, Maryland, since 1968. Dr. Breggin is the author, with Ginger Ross Breggin, of Talking Back to Prozac and The War Against Children.
|